The Datafication of Welfare

Lina Dencik in conversation with Ray Griffin and HECAT – April 15th 2021 – 16:00 GMT

Abstract:

The crisis emerging from the Covid-19 pandemic has elevated both the
relevance of the welfare state as well as the role of platforms and data infrastructures across key areas of public and social life. Whilst the crisis shed light on the ways in which these might intersect, the turn to data-driven systems in public administration has been a prominent development in several countries for quite some time. I focus on the UK as a pertinent example of key trends at the intersection of technological infrastructures and the welfare state.

In particular, using developments in UK welfare sectors as a lens, I advance a two-part argument about the ways in which data infrastructures are transforming state-citizen relations through on the one hand advancing an actuarial logic based on personalised risk and the individualization of social problems (what I refer to as responsibilisation), and on the other, entrenching a dependency on an economic model that perpetuates the circulation of data accumulation (what I refer to as rentierism). These mechanisms, I argue, fundamentally shift the ‘matrix of social power’ (Offe 1984) that made the modern welfare state possible and position questions of data infrastructures as a core component of how we need to understand social change.

Lina Dencik, Co-director of the Data Justice Lab at Cardiff University

Recap:

Each seminar was recorded and featured one or more readings, please find these below.

Click here to watch the recording.

Lina Dencik spoke to us today (April 15) about how the welfare State is changing in response to datafication, and how the concept of data justice can help us to advance our understanding of the issues at hand. We include a selection of Lina’s slides below from her 15 minute presentation.

Image
Image
Image

Many analyses of what happens within the realm of datafication revert immediately to highly ethicised questions around bias. Lina discussed how this collapses our possibility to critically interrogate what is happening in datafication because (for example) when algorithms racially profile people in inappropriate ways it is seen as a technical problem of bias that must be fixed – rather than a problem of the values of the people who built the algorithm. As an alternative to a focus on bias, Lina proposes that we think about data justice from a holistic perspective, thinking about the consequences for our economy and society, and move beyond looking at the technology as though it were static.

Image
Image

Lina also discussed the problem of data rentierism, whereby we must allow our data to be collected as a kind of ‘rent’ we pay for being able to continue to use services in the modern world. This forces us into a cycle of dependency on technical systems which can make it difficult for us to extract ourselves as time passes. Overall this talk was stimulating and engaging – and deals with an issue that only seems to become more pressing with time. Especially in the context of our contemporary moment where we are all dependent on datafied systems as we continue to work from home and socialise on Zoom.

Previous seminar: Theresa O’Keefe, Aline Courtois and Teresa Crew – Precarity.

Next seminar: Evelyn Brodkin in conversation with Mary Murphy and Joe Whelan – Street-Level Welfare.

We would like to express our gratitude to the European Union for funding this event.

The Economy and Society Digital Summer School 2021

DateTime (GMT)Event / TopicSpeakersRecording Link
--Main Archive Page--Full Playlist
February 23rd16:00Ideas Lying AroundNidesh Lawtoo & Lynne LaytonLink
March 4th16:00The Great ReversalElizabeth AndersonLink
March 9th10:00Economy Theology and MarketisationStefan SchwarzkopfLink
March 11th10:00Economic Theology and GovernanceMitchell DeanLink
March 16th16:00Jobseeking & the Labour MarketIlana GershonLink
March 23rd 10:00The Reformation of WelfareRay Griffin & Tom Boland Link
March 25th10:00Justifying WelfareMagnus P. Hansen., Fiona Dukelow, Michael McgannLink
April 13th10:00Precarity and Precarious WorkTheresa O'Keefe, Aline Courtois & Teresa CrewLink
April 15th16:00The Datafication of WelfareLina Dencik & Ray Griffin & HecatLink
April 20th16:00Street-Level WelfareEvelyn Brodkin, Mary Murphy, Joe Whelan
Link
April 22nd10:00Fairground CapitalismArpad SzakolczaiLink
April 27th10:00Work & The Gig EconomyAlex WoodLink
April 29th10:00Rationalities and Moral Economies in Illicit Drug MarketsAngus BancroftLink
May 6th10:00Good Models and Positive MimesisKieran KeohaneLink
May 10th/11th 20:00/10:00The Leviathan of RationalityDamian O'DohertyLink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *